Martha Nussbaum – Political Emotions: Why Love Matters for Justice
February 2, 2026
Why Love Matters for Justice
I have a stack of chapters that I scanned and/or printed years ago. They have been sitting on my desk or shelved away. But I started to purge some things when the year turned from 2025 to 2026.
And yet, it just sits there and takes up space.
I know I need to clear it to make way for other things.
Or at the very least, to be free of the clutter.
I picked up the first stapled copy.
Martha Nussbaum’s Political Emotions: Why Love Matters for Justice. (Amazon Link)
I don’t know why I have Chapter 9, “Tragic and Comic Festivals: Shaping Compassion, Transcending Disgust,” in my possession.
Nussbaum starts with the story of Troy and the Trojan War.
I was researching pain and suffering a few years ago, so I think this chapter was related to my research.
I scroll past the storyline and quickly look for her nuggets of interpretation. And I stumbled upon this:
All societies, however decent and aspiring, face difficult choices. Because the societies we are considering protect a plurality of entitlements for all citizens, considering each person as intrinsically valuable and deserving of concern, they will sometimes encounter cases in which those plural values come into conflict. 15 Tragic spectatorsh1p has already helped citizens learn to identify key opportunities that ought to be protected for all, since their absence poses an especially grave obstacle to a life worthy of human dignity. But it makes another important contribution: tragedies also promote understanding of these conflicts, and of the limits of some common approaches to them. Although the idea of value conflict is prominent in ancient Greek tragedy, it is equally at home in India-seated, indeed, at the very heart of the great epic Mahabharata. So let us turn to a key case from that work.
Nussbaum continues with another example, but that quote has weight and hopefully some sting to what’s been occurring in U.S. news. What occurred in Chicago in the fall of 2025, then shifted to January 2026 in Minneapolis, MN, caused U.S. citizens to take a stand. Two prominent names of American citizens (Renee Good and Alex Pretti), gun control/rights, and the power of public opinion, made Nussbaum’s quote here painfully aware of our current state of affairs.
As I continue reading and taking notes, I realize that this chapter has more than just nuggets. It’s a whole breakdown of how we as a society look at tragedies and how to cope with them.
I’m going to stop here for a moment (1:53 pm) and continue reading and highlighting her pointed words.
Perhaps, I will come back and type her quotes here below for posterity.













Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!